How Recirculation drives engagement and supports reader acquisition

Publishers spend far too much on reader acquisition to lose them for reasons within their control. The tactics that drive reader revenue for publishers is coming at an increasing price — subscriber acquisition costs have grown by approximately 70%, while consumer willingness to pay is steadily declining, according to ProfitWell data.

What is Recirculation?

With a sound Recirculation strategy in place, publishers give readers more opportunities to engage deeper into their site, improving the chances of creating and retaining reader loyalty. Not to mention, engaged readers are more likely to become loyal subscribers.

TL;DR: What is Recirculation, and why does it matter?

Recirculation is a real-time metric that measures how many readers on a page go on to visit another page on the same site. A strong Recirculation strategy turns single-article visits, often from search and social, into deeper reading sessions. That builds reader loyalty, and engaged readers are more likely to become loyal subscribers.

How does Recirculation improve the reader journey?

Recirculation also translates to quality along the reader journey. For example, an effective Recirculation strategy should, at the very least, accomplish two things: 

  • Keep readers moving through your site through valuable links.
  • Ensure that you’re not leading them to content deserts, which can prematurely end their journey.

Where should editors place in-article links to maximize Recirculation?

  1. Show off the depth and quality of your content with a sound Recirculation strategy, so every reader knows that you have more than just the great article they clicked on.
  2. Given the amount of readers that come from external platforms like Google and Facebook, almost all of which are landing on an article rather than your homepage, a clear recirculation strategy can push those readers further down the loyalty journey.
  3. Most publishers rely on programmatic widgets to surface related stories, but related links — chosen by editors at strategic points in the story — are an effective way to encourage deeper visits. Especially on mobile, where more widgets appear at the bottom of the page (where no readers will see them).

One way to promote articles with high Recirculation is through linking, while adapting the strategy based on whether it’s being optimized for search or social. Some additional food for thought:

  • Our research has found that the majority of clicks happen just above the digital fold, at page depths of 400 to 600 pixels (as indicated below), so it’s important to optimize your articles for those related links.

Most clicks on in-article links happen just above the digital fold, at page depths of 400 to 600 pixels.

  • Attempt to use larger links (including linked headlines), which correlate with higher click-through rates.
  • We’ve found that sites with links placed more closely together perform about 2.5x better than sites with more pixels between links.

In-article linking best practices at a glance

Linking factorChartbeat findingEditorial action
Page depthMost clicks happen just above the digital fold, at 400 to 600 pixelsMake sure related links appear in that range of the article
Link sizeLarger links, including linked headlines, correlate with higher click-through ratesUse larger links and linked headlines
Link spacingSites with links placed closer together perform about 2.5x better than sites with more pixels between linksKeep related links close together
Link sourceProgrammatic widgets often sit at the bottom of the page, especially on mobile, where readers won’t see themHave editors choose related links and place them at strategic points in the story

How can newsrooms diagnose and fix low Recirculation using real-time data?

Publishers can quickly identify the drivers of low engagement, but poor Recirculation can have a significant impact as well. To make the most of your content resources, make sure to:

  • Spot popular articles that are a dead end for readers. These represent your best opportunities to drive high-level Recirculation. 
  • Tailor your Recirculation strategy. You can do this based on the visitor type or traffic source that is most prevalent on the page your optimizing.
  • Leverage the Heads Up Display. This shows you where readers are leaving so you can make sure the only reason they’re leaving the page is for another story on the site.
  • Use historical engagement data. This will allow you to find good candidates for related links. 

In general, these common Recirculation tactics hold true for many publishers. However, we’re aware that every audience is different. Therefore, a successful linking strategy should be tailored to the metrics and desired outcomes that help publishers accomplish their specific goals.