How to set internal metrics and competitive benchmarks for success

Publishers shouldn’t have to silo their internal metrics and competitive benchmarks — there are ways to combine the best of both datasets to set clearer performance goals.

I recently co-hosted a webinar with SimilarWeb’s Ariane Turley, where we tackled an issue facing a growing number of organizations — identifying and incorporating the metrics that drive success. Below, more on the tactics you can use to accelerate that process.

TL;DR: How should publishers combine internal metrics with competitive benchmarks?

Pair first-party engagement metrics, such as Engaged Time, Scroll Depth, Recirculation, and Visitor Frequency, with third-party competitive benchmarks, such as traffic trends, digital market share, and bounce rate. Internal metrics show how deeply readers engage and how often they return; competitive benchmarks show how your acquisition and growth compare with peers and the wider market.

Why should publishers combine internal metrics and competitive benchmarks?

To begin, we wanted to address three key questions that arise when attempting to determine KPIs:

1. What are the core metrics that I should consider for a holistic growth strategy?

2. How can global trends inform my KPIs?

3. How can what we know about behaviors during key events impact KPI decisions?

The answers are reliant on the internal and competitive metrics that organizations need to prioritize. Let’s take a deeper dive into those considerations.

Which internal metrics measure long-term reader engagement?

The most useful internal metrics measure three dimensions of reader behavior: engagement, depth, and loyalty. Determining the best metrics for publishers or media can be as simple as using what you already know about readers to your advantage. You can start by asking:

1. Engagement: Are my audiences actually reading what they click on?
2. Depth: How can we drive readers deeper into our site and show more value?
3. Loyalty: How can we optimize the reader journey to encourage users to come back more often?

Here are a few metrics that can help you get started:

Now you can begin to determine the best benchmarks to track performance and support your goals, which we tackle below.

How do publishers establish peer benchmarks for digital traffic?

Establishing effective peer benchmarks requires media organizations to evaluate their performance across three dimensions: category, competitors, and customers. Start by asking the following questions, based on your unique knowledge of your business and peers:

1. Category: How is my publication performing against the news and media industry as a whole? What are the market dynamics that can impact that performance?
2. Competitors: What are my competitors doing? How will that impact us?
3. Customers: What does my audience look like? Are my tactics aligned to acquire new readers and retain the current ones?

Once you’ve addressed those questions, your benchmarks can be based on the data available to you, such as:

The next challenge is determining how these fit within the trends we’re seeing across audiences. More on that in the next section.

Internal metrics vs. competitive benchmarks at a glance

Focus areaInternal metrics (first-party)Competitive benchmarks (third-party)Question it answers
EngagementEngaged Time, Scroll DepthBounce rateAre readers actually reading what they click on?
DepthHomepage CTR, RecirculationDepth of visitAre readers going deeper into the site?
LoyaltyVisitor FrequencyAudience reach and behavior, brand awarenessAre readers coming back more often?
Acquisition and market context—Traffic trends, traffic acquisition, digital market share, audience interestsHow does growth compare with peers and the market?

How can internal and competitive metrics guide reader acquisition?

If the goal is to attract new visitors to your site, understanding the traffic landscape is critical to selecting the metrics that will get you there faster. Another added benefit is that you can compare your organization to the industry as a whole, while getting an idea of how your growth holds up to peers.

What is the current traffic landscape?

From Chartbeat’s analysis, we saw that Total Engaged Time across all publishers rose steeply at the onset of the COVID-19 crisis, but global engagement levels have roughly returned to normal.

When analyzing the data at its relative highs and lows, outliers may emerge. For instance, we saw that live blogs drew an increased number of readers, reflecting a need for timely, reliable information.

And, while average pages per visit have remained steady for mobile visitors, the U.K. and the U.S. have seen declines in pages per visits, indicating a less engaged audience, as we see below.

How does recirculation impact audience retention and loyalty?

Engaging readers and ensuring they go deeper into your content depends on strong Recirculation tactics. To encourage readers to recirculate, publishers should think about where they place related links on article pages.

We’ve found that while most clicks happen in the first 1,000 pixels of a page, there is a long-tail opportunity to recirculate readers who engage more deeply with content. Is that experience enough to ensure that readers return? It will come down to how you measure loyalty at your organization.

Across the news and media landscape, sites in the U.S. have the highest audience loyalty, with 62% of traffic coming from direct sources, according to SimilarWeb. Our data shows that Europe accounts for a large swath of loyal readers as well, based on our quarterly insights.

So, what could those regions be doing better than others? It may come down to their channel-based optimizations. When analyzing loyalty by device, our data shows that referred visitors are less likely to return than readers who come directly to your platforms, especially on mobile.

The impact of direct traffic echoes what we see from SimilarWeb data, with app and web sources leading the way.

What does competitive data reveal about reader loyalty?

Major events tend to be a barometer of the tactics, such as improved Recirculation or improved SEO, that improve audience loyalty. For instance, bounce rates for organic search traffic dropped for all publications in November — likely due to strong coverage of the U.S. election by publishers across the board, according to SimilarWeb.

“What we see is that, in general, bounce rates for organic search traffic are much higher than other sources — this indicates there is a careful balance between solely relying on SEO and having loyal visitors.” — Ariane Turley, SimilarWeb

Luckily for publishers, the onset of fatigue and the inundation of news did not reduce the number of loyal visitors. In fact, the percentage of pageviews from New and Returning visitors increased slightly in the initial period of COVID-19. 

Additionally, traffic from loyal readers continued to grow as a proportion of traffic throughout the year. So was the increase a 2020 outlier or the direct result of strategies put in place to improve loyalty? Check your data — if it’s telling an accurate story of the strategies that kept loyalty strong throughout the year, you’re closer to zeroing in on the benchmarks to grow that metric going forward.

How do major news cycles and breaking events change reader behavior?

To see how engagement metrics and competitive benchmarking can be applied to digital newsrooms, we analyzed data around the 2020 election.

How much traffic did the 2020 U.S. election drive to news sites?

It’s no surprise the election dominated coverage in November, accounting for an average of 35% of all traffic to the top news sites in the U.S., according to SimilarWeb. Additionally, top keywords driving traffic to top news sites in November were almost all election-related.

Larger national publishers appeared to have won the election-related SEO race. To put it in perspective, these SEO wins were in broad keyword groups such as “georgia” and “nevada election results”, rather than the keywords that local newsrooms may focus on for their niche readership.

How much traffic did the 2020 U.S. election drive to news sites?

Search and social traffic mirrored patterns we observed in many previous election cycles, though this year those patterns were spread over a longer time period.

Social traffic began to spike on Election Day and stayed high for the next several days as readers awaited the result. In contrast, search traffic increased as the election neared, but declined soon after the polls closed.

Key takeaways: How can your organization combine internal and competitive metrics?

Digital transformation does not happen overnight, but we hope to have helped along the path toward determining the metrics and competitive benchmarks that make up a data-informed performance strategy. Here are a few key points to consider:

  • There’s no need to silo your internal and competitive metrics. A combination of the two can help you set impactful — and attainable—  KPIs.
  • Trends change quickly. Use the reader data available to evolve your tactics through experimentation.
  • Reader behaviors can vary. Visitor behavior based on dimensions like channel (i.e. search and social) and device type (i.e. desktop and mobile experiences). Based on what we know about loyal readers, it pays to make sure your strategy is adapted to these unique audiences.
  • Find your best untapped opportunities. Competitive metrics don’t have to become a wish list of the tactics your newsroom should be doing, but rather an opportunity.
  • Retention is less costly than acquisition, but it’s equally important. Acquisition is a significant performance indicator, but it’s only half the battle. Your strategy should also prioritize the metrics that measure the experience and loyalty of your readers.